Kenmore Collectibles has closed its retail store in Kenmore Square.

We have moved to an office setting. Our new location is at Kenmore Collectibles, 4074 N Washington Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34234 (Inside Fine Home Consignments)

In this new setting, we will be taking appointments. If you are looking to buy or sell gold / silver / sports cards, Call 617-482-5705, text 617-970-2580 or email us,

You are welcome to wear a mask but it is not mandatory in our office.

About Us

Kenmore Collectibles is now in Sarasota, Florida. Residing at 4074 N. Washington Blvd, we are no longer are a retail card shop.  At this location, we buy sports cards and coins. Also, as a PSA authorized dealer, we can evaluate and submit cards for you (sports and non-sports cards)

Beginning in 1988, Kenmore Collectibles began as a sports card shop on Bromfield Street in Boston’s Downtown Crossing. After riding the heyday of sports collecting for twenty years, J.J. Teaparty Sports Cards decided to expand its business into coins and precious metals.

In 2008, Co-Owners, Mike Gill and Peter Leventhal uprooted their store and moved to the friendly neighborhood of Kenmore Square where they changed the name of the business to Kenmore Collectibles. Today, just as in 1988, Kenmore Collectibles is dedicated to the original goal of offering superior customer service with honesty and integrity.

Fine Home Consignments


I wanted to sell some gold and lucked out finding this place online. The man who assessed my pieces was honest — suggesting I hold onto an antique watch band. I’ve been there twice now and both times was pleasantly shocked by how much money I received for jewelry I no longer wore. I have been telling friends, family and co-workers about how great this place is.


I have been doing business with Peter for close to 20 years. I have purchased cards from Kenmore Collectibles and have found they are very knowledgeable and fairly priced. There is no pressure selling and Peter actually gives you honest feedback about value for money that may not be in his interest for maximizing sales, but is in my interest as customer.

Kevin Q. - 7/6/12

The guys who work there are really helpful and knowledgeable. I went in looking for a simple item (a display case for a baseball card) and just wondered if they had a card for a pretty unknown Red Sox first basemen from 1947. The guy didn’t have one (of course. I don’t know if anybody does), but he went through the trouble to look the player up in a reference book and let me know how many cards were ever issued for the guy, when, and by what company.

Rachel C., Atlanta, GA - 12/23/2008


Kenmore Collectibles, 4074 N Washington Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34234 (Inside Fine Home Consignments)

By Car: Please use the map to the bottom (Google Maps) or other direction services like Mapquest, Yahoo or Google Maps to find us.  Metered Parking is almost always available. Bring some quarters. 12 1/2 minutes per quarter.

Embed Google Maps


Yes. Plenty of spots. Just don’t let the furniture store sign confuse you.

No we do not. Contact JSA (James Spence Authentication Service ( or PSA/DNA ( Send your item out to them.

Yes, but only items with certificates of authenticity from r PSA/DNA, UDA or JSA.  If we are very interested in your item we will help you get your item authenticated.

No, with the exception of graded PSA, SGC, BVG or BGS cards, The exception are Basketball cards up to the year 1987. We will buy Unopened Boxes and Sets depending on what year.

Items over $1000, we pay by check.