Sell Baseball Cards in Sarasota

Kenmore Collectibles buys sports card collections by appointment in the Sarasota area. I work with families, longtime collectors, and sellers who want a clear answer about what their cards may be worth.

I regularly work with sellers in Sarasota, Palmer Ranch, Gulf Gate, Siesta Key, and nearby communities. I buy entire collections, not just the obvious star cards.

Call Peter About Selling Baseball Cards

Prefer texting? Send photos to 617-482-5705.

Send Photos for Review

What I am looking for

inherited collections
longtime collectors ready to part with cards they have owned for years
vintage baseball cards
unopened boxes
PSA / SGC / BGS graded cards
complete or partial sets
better star cards

Not every collection is a good fit

I am usually not the best buyer for large groups of common 1980s–1990s cards, most newer commons, Pokémon-only collections, or cards that would require a full appraisal before I can tell whether there is meaningful value.

Process

Call Peter or send a few photos
I tell you whether it looks like a fit
If it makes sense, we discuss whether I can make an offer or recommend the best next step.

For more details about what I buy and how I evaluate collections, visit my main We Buy Sports Cards page.