1933
Earl Averill
Moe Berg
Mickey Cochrane
Eddie Collins
Joe Cronin
Dizzy Dean
Leo Durocher
Jimmie Foxx
Lou Gehrig
Charlie Gehringer
Goose Goslin
Lefty Grove
Gabby Hartnett
Rogers Hornsby
Waite Hoyt
Carl Hubbell
Chuck Klein
Napoleon Lajoie
Tony Lazzeri
Pepper Martin
Mel Ott
Herb Pennock
Sam Rice
Babe Ruth
Joe Sewel
Al SImmons
Bill Terry
Pie Traynor
Arky Vaughn
Lloyd Waner
Paul Waner
Hack Wilson

​

1938

Joe DiMaggio

Bobby Doer

Bob Feller

​

1939

Ted Williams

​

1940

George Kelly

Connie Mack

Casey Stengel

Joe Jackson (not rookie)

​

1941

Lou Boudreau

Dom DiMaggio

Johnny Mize

Pee Wee Reese

Phil Rizzuto

Sibby Sisti

Johnny Vander Meer

​

1948

Yogi Berra

Ralph Kiner

Stan Musial

Johnny Sain

Red Schoendienst

​

1949

Richie Ashburn

Larry Doby

Gil Hodges

George Kell

Ted Kluszewski

Hal Newhouser

Satchel Paige

Johnny Pesky

Robin Roberts

Jackie Robinson

Duke Snider

Early Wynn

​

1951

Whitey Ford

Nellie Fox

Monte Irvin

Mickey Mantle

Willie Mays

​

1952

Mickey Mantle

Billy Martin

Eddie Mathews

Willie Mays

Gil McDougald

Minnie Minoso

​

1953

Jim Gilliam

​

1954

Ernie Banks

Al Kaline

Hank Aaron

​

1955

Roberto Clemente

Sandy Koufax

Harmon Killebrew

​

​